At an lavish speakeasy-style gathering hosted at Raffles hotel on Whitehall this week, prominent figures from the remaining ranks of the Conservative party marked the Spectator’s annual political honors.
With the magazine’s editorial line still just about support the Conservatives, despite the party confront severe challenges from Reform UK, it was unsurprising that much of the gossip at the champagne-fuelled event was about whether Kemi Badenoch’s job faced threats.
Leadership Rivalries Emerge at Awards
James Cleverly, who unsuccessfully ran, made pointed remarks during his speech at the naked ambition of his shadow cabinet colleague, a key rival – who is Badenoch’s biggest threat.
“Do I seek her position? Will I make a move against the leader to take over? Certainly not,” the experienced politician informed the amused crowd as he opened the awards ceremony.
Jenrick, who came second, and has been pitching alarmingly to the right to take on Nigel Farage, responded with humor. His own manoeuvres have been anything but subtle.
Deadline to Challenge Starts
Months ago, one of the Tory leader’s disgruntled backbenchers set up a countdown clock online showing remaining time until Conservative rules allow rivals to mount a challenge. That period concludes this weekend.
At that point, the Tory leader’s critics can formally request to trigger a contest. The rules changed last year raising the required support, now demanding thirty percent from parliamentary colleagues must endorse, up from 15%, establishing a tougher standard for those trying to oust her.
Possible Contenders and Backing
But could any putative rivals – Jenrick foremost among them – persuade the 36 MPs required to start the process? Tory insiders point to previous nomination totals in the leadership contest: 28 in the first round. “That’s your starting point,” according to insiders.
Many exist of Tory MPs willing to share their frustrations about Badenoch: her style, her decision-making, her ability to cut through. However, generally, they are hesitant about committing yet another act of political regicide at this time.
Breathing Space and Election Anxieties
Some Conservative MPs also believe the leader's conference address during the fall gathering, unveiling plans to remove property tax on primary homes, secured her temporary relief.
“Although dissatisfied with Kemi’s leadership we will act cautiously regarding a change. Voters already perceive we fight like rats in a sack. We don’t need to give them further confirmation,” one MP said.
That is not to say planning has ceased. “Kemi has until May. Upcoming council polls could be disastrous for the party. No one will desire to assume leadership preemptively and have to own the result. But afterwards, we must find a leader capable of guiding toward renewal,” a frontbench source said.
Survey Data and Public Perception
The polls already suggest Badenoch has made little progress among voters in the past twelve months and that she has fallen in personal approval. At -22 points, her standing is lower compared to her rival and another colleague, per recent polling.
Data from YouGov further reveals that Badenoch has convinced only 12% of Britons she is ready for higher office. The outlook improves with party supporters, over half stating they approve of her performance as party leader, with fewer than a third opposing her continuation into the national campaign.
Future Scenarios and Party Strategies
Despite mixed feelings among base voters, a general agreement exists among the MPs that Badenoch will not be the one to lead the party into the next election.
The main division is whether it would better to replace her in May and have a chance at stopping Reform’s momentum – or delay until nearer the election date when Farage might have imploded, and public receptiveness improves toward Conservative messages.
It is no secret that Jenrick thinks he is the man for the job. However, associates claim he has no plans to move now, and is among those advocating patience until spring.
Other Candidates and Approaches
Some speculate that the party’s potential saviour from less expected with a lower profile (the shadow climate secretary is sometimes suggested) or a member of the new intake without strong associations to previous governments.
Another former candidate, is considered a consensus builder, and has been keeping his powder dry. His allies say he thinks there is no alternative than current leadership, since a new leader immediately would inherit an even more difficult situation.
However, if a contest were to be triggered, some would certainly encourage his candidacy, and he may be persuadable to give it another shot. A small group of centrist MPs are organizing opposition efforts to prevent Jenrick from being crowned from winning.
Conservative Movement and Political Considerations
An influential insider cautioned that the “energy is all on the right” within and beyond the party, mentioning names like several prominent MPs. “Opportunity exists for Cleverly given his experience and membership connections, while others oppose Jenrick completely.”
“Quite a lot of minds potential agreements or coalition with Reform eventually. Recent parliamentary divisions regarding assisted suicide and decriminalising abortion there was a lot of ‘we need to kick the people of dissenters while Reform privately is ‘you’ve got some Lib Dems sympathizers must go. This advantages in Robert’s favour a bit.”
Yet another source noted: “The outcome remains a foregone conclusion. We could have a strong competition involving multiple candidates – other prominent figures. The idea that the rightwing candidate always wins the membership is not necessarily the case.”